The great medical and social harm of
alcohol abuse is well established.
In the case of cardiovascular
disease, however, alcohol appears to have conflicting effects. At
high levels, alcohol use can contribute to a range of
cardiovascular disorders. At low to moderate levels it can still
produce some harmful effects, but these may be balanced by some
benefits. However, further research is needed in this area.
On the harmful side, alcohol
consumption at any level tends to raise blood pressure, the
effect appearing at the lowest levels of intake and increasing
with the amount consumed. Considered alone, this must be presumed
to increase the risk of diseases associated with raised blood
pressure, such as heart attack and stroke. Alcohol is high in
energy and its consumption can contribute to being overweight,
which is a cardiovascular risk factor.
Alcohol use can also raise blood
triglyceride levels and thus complicate the effects of elevated
blood cholesterol levels when they are present. Very heavy
alcohol intake can cause cardiomyopathy with heart failure, and
binge drinking is associated with stroke. In population studies
alcohol consumption beyond moderate levels is associated with
greater mortality from heart attack and cardiovascular disease
generally.
Moderate alcohol intake can be
defined as no more than two standard drinks of alcohol daily for
women and no more than four for men. (A standard drink is 10gm of
alcohol.) At a given level, alcohol has more harmful effects on
women than on men. However, in population studies, low to
moderate alcohol intake is not associated with a higher
cardiovascular mortality than occurs among teetotallers and may
even be associated with slightly lower mortality.
The reasons for this finding are
unclear and subject to continuing research. In the case of
cardiovascular disease, it is scientifically premature to
conclude that moderate alcohol intake produces a cardiovascular
benefit on balance, but it seems certain that it poses little or
negligible risk to most users.
In view of these considerations, the
Heart Foundation makes the following recommendations and
conclusions:
- The relationship of various
levels of alcohol intake to cardiovascular disease and
its risk factors should be studied further. With
knowledge of community patterns of consumption, this
permits an estimate of alcohol's contribution to overall
cardiovascular health status in Australia, as well as its
effects on particular groups.
- On cardiovascular and other
health grounds, there is no justification for
recommending that non-drinkers of alcohol should take up
the habit or that any drinkers should increase their
intake.
- On those same grounds, there are
strong reasons for all people who drink alcohol to limit
intake to moderate levels.
- Those whose blood pressure or
blood cholesterol levels are high, or who are overweight,
have additional reasons for moderating or avoiding use.
Alcohol consumers on medication to lower their blood
pressure, should either stop drinking or restrict their
intake to one or two drinks per day at most, with the
hope of reducing the need for such medication.